“What Are Your Thoughts on AI making art and writing?” he asked

The publishing company Starship Sloane has relaunched the classic sf magazines Galaxy and Worlds of If. I have some stories in those new publications and there’s an interview with me in the forthcoming Worlds of If–and here’s how I responded to the question about AI in art and writing.

I have been in a state of existential angst for years now regarding the intrusion of AI into what I consider to be the sacred realm of human inspiration and creativity. What are your thoughts on AI making art and writing?

I feel your pain. I am part of the writing community’s class-action lawsuit against Anthropic AI which “scraped” our books, used them in a way that amounted to plagiarizing style and story. They used my novel CITY COME A’WALKIN’ and my ECLIPSE trilogy, and more. But they did this, I re-emphasize, to so very many others too. And Anthropic has settled for $1.5 billion-–but that’s to be divided between a whole lot of writers, when it is paid out!

I feel very strongly about AI “writing” as plagiarism and as being anti-creativity; I feel very strongly that any acceptance of AI as “writer” will lead at best to a general rot in culture, a sludge of AI-slop storytelling. It also screws over people who don’t realize they can develop their own writing better without AI.

Giving the AI a prompt or outline does not make you a writer. I believe that anyone who uses AI for the arts—and it’s happening in music and graphic art too—is being fundamentally dishonest, revoltingly lazy, and they’re cheating themselves along with the whole world.

The Slums of Heaven

The Slums of Heaven
by JS

A false god usurped Heaven
And gave way to insanity
The Absolute doesn’t do a Heaven;
Would not stoop to that inanity

The Archon sank into a black hole
Where now he spins forever
And Heaven without a Tyrant Soul
Has no organizing center

Its architecture fell apart
–no tyrant holds its kitschy shape–
Residents put cracked blocks in a cart
to cobble a shabby cityscape

The real saints left centuries ago
Jesus shook the dust off his boots
He sighed and muttered oh dear oh no
Then ascended to the Absolute

I toured the place during a N.D.E.
(Passing through several planes)
The reconstruction was done crappily
And it’s marred with dubious stains

Former saints now mutter and cough
Begging for manna on streets of gold
The golden paint is chipping off
And the air is growing cold

They huddle at fires in rusting barrels
Which formerly held cheap grace
They try to remember Christmas carols
And there’s soot on everyone’s face

Communion wine’s gulped by the crowd
They drink it like no tomorrow
They stagger past the grimy clouds
what they don’t steal, they borrow

I don’t recommend that offramp
When you’re driving the afterworld
Heaven’s slums are sleazy and damp
And the gates are no longer pearled